Speech recognition software in Vista
July 24th, 2007 by
Phil Collins
The new windows operating system, Microsoft Vista, comes with free speech recognition software built in. Its aim is to allow you to navigate around Vista using speech as well as dictating in most applications. You can dictate in almost every application within Vista including Microsoft Office. I’m using the speech recognition software and Microsoft word 2007 to write this blog entry. Unfortunately it’s not as easy as I’d hoped. In the office we are trying out Nuance Naturally Speaking Dragon Dictate version nine, which seems to be a lot easier than this one. I’ve had to correct Vista quite a few times so far but that could be an issue with the training programme. In dragon dictate you have the option of reading particular verses from books, whereas with Vista you’re almost reading your own training programme.
I’m not so sure this is faster than typing it but then I am a fast typist. It could also be down to learning my voice as well, this is the first time I’ve used this to dictate anything, up until now I’ve only played with using Vista to navigate around. Some things are down to user error such as continuing to say end of line except I kept forgetting to say go to at the beginning of the instruction.
Listening to Kirstin dictate to Dragon earlier today it seemed an awful lot easier and there were a lot less mistakes but maybe with time Vista will catch up, then again it is free (Vista originally dictated this as sister is three, very nearly close enough) whereas Dragon costs £50.00 for the basic version.
Suffice to say I’m not convinced with the voice recognition built into Vista just yet.
(Using the voice recognition software I’ve just managed to copy the post from word, then open Mozilla Firefox, go to this website, login and paste the text as the new blog entry)
UPDATE: I’ve just dictated the about page of this here website to both Dragon and Vista. After dictation I went through and did as many of the touch-ups, including strikethroughs and links where appropriate, as I could with the voice software.
With the Dragon software I managed it all - every font change, link and strikethrough. There were a couple of mistakes which managed to correct in the text using the voice recognition and I never had to touch the keyboard at all. I managed it all in about ten minutes.
With Vista I gave up after ten minutes. I managed to dictate the text but there were so many mistakes and there is so much I couldn’t do. I couldn’t even make the text bold let alone add a link to a selection of text. I think Vista also tries to be too clever and won’t give you options on text if it’s grammatically incorrect, which is a good bonus, but it’s a pain if it doesn’t tell you why it’s wrong and will just pretend to not understand you.
Overall I find it strange that a third-party application such as Dragon Dictate actually integrates more with Word than Microsofts own speech recognition program. Dragon understands the command “strikethrough” when you have text selected and correctly strikes that text. Vista just thinks you’re trying to replace it with the word.
Posted in Everything else |
No Comments »
